As we expand the impact of procurement beyond savings, one of the most frequently cited objectives is process efficiency. In theory, if procurement can help the company execute internal processes more swiftly, they can… something, something, something (?). Process efficiency is good, and savings are good. But neither will have any real impact if we don’t understand why we are driving them.
The retail industry is a perfect case example for the need to understand the big picture impact of process efficiency. When you work for a B2C company, customer satisfaction is the answer to every question. In retail, the benefit of every project must be traceable all the way to the store.
The wholesale goal of retail: customer experience and satisfaction.
Sourcing project teams usually sit down and articulate their goals and objectives at the outset of the process. Too often they are focused on the impact of the product or service on the company and its employees when they should trace that efficiency forward to the value it creates for customers. This perspective provides the context for many of the decisions made during the sourcing process:
Why should office supplies need to be easier to order?
So marketing doesn’t have to interrupt their work on the new ad that will drive shoppers’ grocery lists this week.
Why are we going through a lengthy equipment testing process?
To prevent customers from being inconvenienced at the deli while we repair the slicers (again).
Which supplier should we award the fixtures and millwork contract to?
The one whose product best evokes a farmer’s market, ultimately increasing produce sales.
In a retail environment, one of the most dangerous lines procurement can draw is between direct and indirect spend. This division is practical enough, especially for categorization purposes, but it creates the impression that indirect spend matters less than direct spend does. Even indirect spend must create value for the end customer. Every dollar the organization spends – whether it is an investment in inventory or to buy copy paper for headquarters – should efficiently advance the interests of the customer. That is what defines valuable process efficiency in retail.
Placing a value on retail intangibles.
Case in point: Kemper Freeman is the owner of Bellevue Square, a multilevel mall in Seattle, Washington. He is a bricks and mortar king in an increasingly digital commerce world. Despite the lackluster performance of retail chains like Macys, J. Crew, Sears, Charming Charlie, and J.C. Penney, his business is booming. He characterizes his approach to customer attraction as “emotional fulfillment”, and it is something eCommerce businesses can’t compete with.
As was recently explained in a Wall Street Journal article about Freeman, emotional fulfillment is “the joy customers take in seeing, touching, sniffing and testing the product before they pull out the credit card.” For a retail business to be driven by the creation of emotional fulfillment, every employee – from store clerks to corporate procurement to janitorial staff – has to buy in and place the customer at the center of every effort they make.
Given this context, what does process efficiency mean in retail?
Procurement-enabled retail process efficiency removes barriers between demand and supply so that value can be created for customers. Process efficiency is not getting to the end of a sourcing project faster and it is not about making corporate roles easier. Efficiency ensures that the flow of products and services are not interrupted, and they certainly don’t take customer facing roles away from their primary focus. Even in procurement, the customer should remain the central focus, and the goals for every project should be tied to a barrier removed or a benefit advanced. These are the only efficiency gains that matter.
As the procurement authority, Kelly Barner’s experience touches on every aspect of retail and many other industries, which she shares in blogs with Determine readers regularly.
If you’d like to see what procurement process efficiency looks like when it’s optimized, schedule a personalized demonstration of the Determine Cloud Platform.